One of the great things about writing societies, social media, writer’s festivals, workshops and casual writer’s groups is that there is a plethora of advice out there for the aspiring author who is keen to turn their dream into a reality. Whether that’s the dream of turning that idea that’s been invading your thoughts for months into a manuscript, or the dream of putting the manuscript you poured your heart and soul into out there to be consumed and enjoyed by the masses. And that advice can come from all sources: from other authors, to readers, to academics, to industry professionals.
There are so many options on how to get advice on your writing journey.
You can type a question into your social media feeds and receive replies from all over with suggestions and tips.
You can spend a few dollars to attend a workshop with someone whose worked in the publishing industry for years and is able to explain the ins and outs of how it all works.
You can sign up for a course with a qualified academic or writer where you learn how to improve your technique, or write a banging query letter, or develop the perfect marketing strategy.
You can go and listen to your favourite author talk at a writer’s festival or a book launch about how on earth they did it, and how they have built it into a full and fulfilling career.
You can make friends with people who are going through the same journey as you and learn from each other through multiple conversations and commiserations.
And most certainly as you start to prepare your manuscript for publication, you will likely have an entire team of beta readers, editors, publishers ect. reviewing your work. They will suggest changes on how to make the story engaging, offer advice on how to improve your technique and give helpful strategy on how to get your book to the right audiences.
Here’s the problem: at some point you will inevitably receive conflicting advice.
“Show don’t tell.”
“There are absolutely times where telling is the only option.”
“Your character should be likeable.”
“Actually, the most complex characters someone you don’t want to root for.”
“Use that popular trope.”
“No, I never want to see that trope in any fiction ever again.”
“First person is better than third person.”
“Present tense is the way to go these days.”
“Have Multiple POVs.”
“Have a Single POV.”
“Stand-alone novels don’t sell, there needs to be a sequel.”
“Represent all” vs “Don’t appropriate a culture you don’t understand.”
“Self publishing is the better option these days, don’t bother with the traditional route.”
So many opinions. So little brain space for the emerging writer. How do you decide what advice to take?
As I was writing The Barren Peace and planning subsequent books, I was overwhelmed by the amount of advice and opinion out there. What I worked out is that much of it is based on personal experience or the experience of people around them. But here’s the thing about personal experience: everyone’s is different.
One person’s successful self publishing journey is not akin to someone else’s self publishing journey that resulted in absolutely no sales whatsoever. A first person, present tense, singular POV novel is not going to work for every kind of story. Some tropes work better in certain genres than others. And there is a time for telling rather than showing depending on the structure of your novel.
I genuinely don’t think it’s ever realistic to say there is any piece of writing advice which is completely wrong, despite that being the question you might get asked on Threads or X. I think the relevant question is actually “what piece of writing advice didn’t work for you in this particular thing you’ve created.”
Because here’s the thing: what worked in one novel also might not work in another novel by the same author. Across your career, if you stay in the writing industry, you will experiment with techniques and styles. You will take different pieces of advice depending on what you’re trying to create.
The moral to this story? Don’t panic. See the advice you’re getting as helpful, but subjective. But be okay with exploring and deciding what works for you. And if someone tells you your way is wrong? That’s fine, they’re entitled to their opinion. And you’re entitled to make your journey exactly the way you want it to be.